1st Edition

Rethinking Middle Powers in the Asian Century New Theories, New Cases

    252 Pages
    by Routledge

    252 Pages
    by Routledge



    The term "middle power" is conceptually fragile. Some scholars have even argued for abandoning it. This book argues that the concept needs to be analysed more profoundly and that new analytical tools need to be developed to better understand the phenomenon. The traditional approach, based on Western states, is insufficient and has become increasingly irrelevant in a transformed global environment. Instead of drawing from a single theory of international relations, the contributors have chosen to build upon a wide range of theories in a deliberate demonstration of analytic eclecticism. A pluralistic approach provides stronger explanations while remaining analytically and intellectually rigorous. Many of the theory contributions are reconsidering how the largely "Western" bases of such theorising need revising in light of the "emerging middle powers", many of which are in Asia.



    Presenting a strong argument for studying middle powers, this book explores both the theory and empirical applications of the concept by rethinking the definition and characteristics of middle powers using a range of case studies. It examines changes in the study of middle powers over the last decade, proposing to look at the concept of middle powers in a coherent and inclusive manner. Finally, it aims to further the discussion on the evolution of the international system and provides sound conclusions about the theoretical usefulness and empirical evolution of middle powers today.



    List of figures and tables



    Notes on contributors



    Introduction



    DAVID WALTON AND THOMAS S. WILKINS



    PART I



    Theoretical approaches



    1 Middle powers: A comprehensive definition and typology



    TANGUY STRUYE DE SWIELANDE



    2 The historical determination of the middle power concept



    GABRIELE ABBONDANZA



    3 Defining middle powers through IR theory: Three images



    THOMAS S. WILKINS



    4 Interlocutors for peace? Bringing middle powers in from the theoretical cold



    ALLAN PATIENCE AND CHIRAAG ROY



    5 Middle powers in the agency-structure debate



    FEDERICA DE PANTZ



    6 Too big to fit? Locating "rising powers" regarding the middle power category



    JOAN DEAS



    7 Interrogating middle powers’ behaviour



    CATHERINE JONES



    8 Faith no more: Reflections on the distinction between traditional and emerging middle powers



    EDUARD JORDAAN



    9 Middle power assertiveness as a behavioural model in foreign policy



    ANDRIY TYUSHKA



    PART II



    Case studies



    10 Middle powers and power shifts: Australian foreign policy towards China and Japan



    DAVID WALTON



    11 Adjusting the middle to fit the frame: Canada in the changing global order



    JEREMY PALTIEL AND KIM RICHARD NOSSAL



    12 India: Breaking out of the middle power straitjacket?



    EMILIAN KAVALSKI



    13 The case of Pakistan: Middlepowermanship as a role



    DOROTHÉE VANDAMME



    14 The Singapore paradox: The "little red dot" as a "middle power"



    LAM PENG ER



    15 Meddling middle powers: Can diplomacy crack the North Korean conundrum?



    VIRGINIE GRZELCZYK



    16 Middle power hybridisation and China



    JONATHAN H. PING



    Conclusion



    TANGUY STRUYE DE SWIELANDE AND DOROTHÉE VANDAMME



    Afterword



    ANDREW F. COOPER



    Index

    Biography

    Tanguy Struye de Swielande is Professor of International Relations at the Université catholique de Louvain, Belgium.



    Dorothée Vandamme is a Research Assistant at the Université catholique de Louvain, Belgium.



    David Walton is Senior Lecturer in Asian Studies and International Relations at Western Sydney University, Australia.



    Thomas Wilkins is Senior Lecturer in the Department of Government and International Relations at the University of Sydney, Australia.