1st Edition

Physicists in Conflict From Antiquity to the New Millennium

By Neil A. Porter Copyright 1998

    Dialogue in science is essential for progress. But when dialogue becomes conflict or further intensifies to persecution the situation is harmful not only to science, but also to the wider society in which science exists. This is true whether the conflict is internal, in the case of Boltzmann, or external, as with Galileo and Oppenheimer against their respective authorities.

    Physicists in Conflict: From Antiquity to the New Millennium examines the nature of conflict in science through examples chosen from the history of physics. These cases fall into three broad themes: physicists in conflict with religion, conflict between physicists on significant scientific issues, and physicists in conflict with each other and politicians on matters of public policy with scientific content. Conflict is singled out as a common element in otherwise disparate areas precisely because it has characteristics that are common to the different cases, and sometimes the similarities are remarkable, such as in the cases of Galileo and Oppenheimer.

    The book is suitable for general readers with an interest in physics as well as for undergraduate physics students and professional physicists. It will also be of interest to those working in the fields of peace and conflict studies.

    Introduction
    Religion Rampant: Hypatia, Roger Bacon, Giordano Bruno
    Galileo and the Inquisition
    Kepler
    Internal Conflict
    The Atomic Theory and Positivist Philosophy
    N-Rays
    Einstein and the Copenhagen School
    Oppenheimer and the AEC
    Blackett, Cherwell, Tizard: Operational Research and Total War
    The Big Bang versus Continuous Creation
    Multiple versus Plural Photon and Particle Production
    Missing Magnetic Monopoles
    Conclusions
    Postscript References
    Glossary
    Bibliographical Discussion
    Bibliography
    Index

    Biography

    Neil A. Porter

    "…very clear, accessible, and quite accurate survey of a number of fascinating debates within physics."
    -ISIS